Every town has a shop that visitors work into their routine, and in Red River that shop is painted red. The Candy Crate, at 300 West Main Street, is a nostalgic candy store and gift shop whose tall carved wooden greeter out front has watched generations of families come through the door. Owner Dirk Arnold repeats what a customer once told him: "We sell happiness."
The signature product is Candy Mountain Fudge, a cream-and-butter fudge the shop has been making since 1990. It is made at 8,750 feet, and more than forty varieties rotate through the case over the course of a year. The New Mexico flavors anchor the case: Green Chile Pistachio Fudge and Red Chile Chocolate Pecan Fudge, both made with New Mexico chile powder and nuts. Seasonal flavors such as Key Lime, Penuchi Nut, and Pumpkin Chocolate Chip are anticipated all year by regulars who plan their trips around them.
The fudge is only the beginning. The Candy Crate built its name on nostalgia, and the shelves carry the retro and hard-to-find candies that send adults straight back to childhood. Around them are fine chocolates, glazed nuts, ice cream, New Mexico coffee, and foods that reflect the culture of New Mexico, along with gifts and souvenirs. It is the kind of store where a quick stop for one thing turns into a slow lap around every aisle.
What makes the shop a Red River institution is the tradition it has become. For many families, a visit to The Candy Crate is a fixed part of every trip to town. The store has been here long enough that children who once visited on vacation with their parents now bring their own children in. That is a rare kind of staying power for a Main Street business, and it is earned one sample and one slab of fudge at a time.
First-time visitors should start at the fudge case and try a New Mexico flavor they cannot get at home. The Green Chile Pistachio pairs the state's signature chile with a rich, sweet base, and the Red Chile Chocolate Pecan brings a gentle warmth to deep chocolate. Take a box for the cabin, and a bag of something nostalgic for the drive home.
The Candy Crate stands at 300 West Main Street in Red River, an easy stroll from anywhere in town. And for those who cannot make it to the mountains, the shop ships, in its own words, "a little bit of Red River" anywhere. Happiness, it turns out, travels well.